Smoke detector test - comparisons. Com 2024

The best smoke detectors, fire detectors in comparison

sort by  
  Best recommendation

1,4Excellent

Smoke Detector Egg Electronics Egg 650 Smoke Detector Fire Detector
  •  Easy-press button for operation from the ground
  •  Reduced test volume
  •  Mute function
 

1,7good

Smoke detector Hekatron Genius PLUS the smart smoke detector fire detector
  •  Operable from the ground
  •  Easy to install
  •  Frequency-optimized signal tone
  •  Optical alarm and status display
Price-performance winner

1,8good

Smoke Detector Pyrexx Fire Detector
  •  color selection
  •  On request drilling attachment possible
  •  Favorable
  •  
 

1,9good

Smoke detector Busch-Jäger fire detector
  •  Operable from the ground
  •  Muting possible
 

2,0good

Smoke detector Elro Cavius ​​Smoke detector Fire detector
  •  Permanently installed battery
  •  Very easy
  •  Optical smoke detection sensor
Name Smoke Detector Egg Electronics Egg 650 Smoke Detector Fire Detector Smoke detector Hekatron Genius PLUS the smart smoke detector fire detector Smoke Detector Pyrexx Fire Detector Smoke detector Busch-Jäger fire detector Smoke detector Elro Cavius ​​Smoke detector Fire detector
Price Check price Check price Check price Check price Check price
comparison result
Note on the comparative grade

The Best producttest-vergleiche.com1,4Excellentsmoke detector

TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com1,7goodsmoke detector

Best Performance test-vergleiche.com1,8goodsmoke detector

TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com1,9goodsmoke detector

TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,0goodsmoke detector

Manufacturers Egg Electronics Hekatron Pyrexx Busch-Jäger elro
Color white white white white white
Form period period period period period
Weight 180 grams 145 grams 181 grams 240 grams 100 grams
Battery Lithium Lithium Lithium Alkaline Lithium
Battery life 10 years 10 years 12 years 10 years 10 years
Cover 60m² 60m² 60 m² 60m² 60m²
Alarm in decibels 85 85 85 85 88
functional test
Technical effect Photo-optical Photo-optical Photo-optic & thermal Photo-optical Photo-optical
Pollution Compensation
installation method screws self-adhesive self-adhesive screws screws
Networking
Features Due to the "Silent-Stand-By" technique also suitable for the bedroom. There is also a 5 year warranty. At night, the LED indicator will automatically dim. Genius works with special beep for better perception. Built-in lithium battery to avoid bothersome battery replacement. KA The dimensions are miniature and correspond to a golf ball. 10 minutes break option for cooking.
Benefits
  •  Easy-press button for operation from the ground
  •  Reduced test volume
  •  Mute function
  •  Operable from the ground
  •  Easy to install
  •  Frequency-optimized signal tone
  •  Optical alarm and status display
  •  color selection
  •  On request drilling attachment possible
  •  Favorable
  •  
  •  Operable from the ground
  •  Muting possible
  •  Permanently installed battery
  •  Very easy
  •  Optical smoke detection sensor
Conclusion An optimal lifesaver, which was also judged by the Stiftung Warentest as the winner of the comparison. The price starting from 17 Euro is the cheapest among the test models and the device convinces by decisive characteristics like Easy-Press-Button, Silent-Stand-By and long life. Reliable smoke detector, which is available in many innovative variants. The Q seal stands for high quality especially for smoke detectors. The smoke detector does not require an additional LED flashing light and does not interfere. A compact protection device, for a fair price. Equipped with Q label! A shapely and unobtrusive design, which is easy to use. Only the mounting material is called unstable. An innovative smoke detector, which impresses in the smoke detector comparison mainly by its mini format. Unfortunately, due to the background noise not recommended for bedrooms.
To the Amazon offer

Our comparison chart for Smoke detector comparison does not replace one Smoke detector testin which a special Smoke detector test winner can be recommended. In order to increase the added value for our readers, we may link to an external smoke detector test trusted sources. Only you decide which model your personal Smoke detector test winner is.

Smoke Detector Guide - To save lives

The worst nightmare of a human. It burns in your own home and you do not notice it in time to save yourself and the family. To protect life and limb, smoke detectors have been developed. In case of emergency, they reach a volume of over 80 decibels to reach every ear. From a noise level of 80 dB, everyone demonstrably gets excited and immediately understands the situation as an emergency.

At a glance

  • Smoke alarms are designed to warn people living in the area they are in. They can neither protect property nor prevent fire spreading. The first priority is to protect the sleeping from suffocation by being able to escape in time by the acoustic warning.
  • Prior to 15 years, the long-term project "Smoke Detectors Save Lives" was initiated. 800 fire deaths per year were too many 800, which required urgent action. In the year 2015 statistics were able to determine a halving on 400 burn victims per year. The national smoke detector obligation is hobbyhorse of the action.
  • The Federal Association of Technical Fire Protection eV 2015 came to an alarming interim balance for care institutions. Already in July 2015 fires in retirement homes have doubled, compared to last year. This shows how endangered especially the elderly are, as their mobility and responsiveness are impaired. You depend on early warning and assistance!

Most common causes of fire - save smoke detectors

The biggest hazards For humans and animals, fire, water and natural disasters become reality. By the way, tangible assets are also endangered, which affects the existence in bad cases. Billions of euros are paid year by year by insurance companies to regulate damage. Unfortunately, dead people can not find a way to bring the world back to life.

The majority of the population probably thinks that general inattention would be responsible for most fires. Statistics on fire causes show something different! In approximately 35 percent Of the cases, the causes in the field of electricity can be found. Just 17 percent are attributed to human error. The best known example is probably the cigarette in bed. Just 3 percent accounted for candles, which caused a fire.

If you look at the Statistics as regards the Electricity on, apply Dryer as the main cause. Close behind are television sets and refrigerators and freezers. Washing machines and dishwashers are at 6 percent sources of fire. All these devices can be found in every home and are virtually standard in our households. How should one avoid fires at all? Do we have to go back to the washboard and scrub the laundry clean? Click also through our Tumble dryer comparisonHere we give important advice.

The 10 most important tips for avoiding fire in your own walls
1. Only operate electrical devices under supervision!
2. Disconnect all electrical equipment from the mains - pull the plug!
3. Express cigarettes correctly!
4. Put away matches, lighters and the like and secure them from the hands of children!
5. Place combustibles such as candles at a sufficient distance!
6. Reduce rapid fire triggers such as dry plants, old paper, etc.!
7. Avoid electrical devices without a test mark!
8. Do not overuse the socket strips!
9. Close the chimney doors before leaving the room
10. Never put hot ashes in the trash can

Who comes across supposed bargains from abroad, should first the Verifier flag check. The German GS mark for example, stands for tested safety. It is a voluntary seal, which certifies a preliminary examination. It is trustworthy and stands for safe use. Electrical appliances with VDE mark certify compliance with the highest safety standards and are just as reliable.

Often, the cheap devices are installed inferior and there is a risk to mutate the number one cause of fire. Fairy lights, sockets, kettles and other small appliances should always be checked for safety. Insignificant loose contacts or faulty insulation can cause unaffordable damage and cost lives in an emergency. Incidentally, you will find more about high-quality socket strips in the large version Power strip comparison.

Smoke detectors are required

The smoke detectors regulates each state individually in its state building regulation. All regulations are the same in at least the following respects:

  • At least one smoke detector must be installed in each bedroom, nursery and hallway. The corridors departing from these rooms are considered as escape routes and must therefore be equipped as well.

What differs depending on the state, are maintenance obligations and by whom they must be made. The following table is for your overview (as of January / 2016)

StateGuidelines smoke detectors compulsory
Baden-WürttembergEverywhere necessary, if necessary
BavariaEverywhere necessary, if necessary
Rheinland-PfalzEverywhere necessary, if necessary
SaarlandEverywhere necessary, if necessary
HessenEverywhere necessary, if necessary
ThuringiaEverywhere necessary, if necessary
Nordrhein-WestfalenEverywhere necessary, if necessary
SaxonyOnly in new buildings and conversions
Sachsen-AnhaltEverywhere necessary, if necessary
BerlinNo smoke detectors required yet
BrandenburgNo smoke detectors required yet
Lower SaxonyEverywhere necessary, if necessary
BremenEverywhere necessary, if necessary
HamburgEverywhere necessary, if necessary
Mecklenburg-VorpommernEverywhere necessary, if necessary
Schleswig-HolsteinEverywhere necessary, if necessary

All statements without guarantee

How do smoke detectors work?

They are perfect for the simple retrofitting from sleeping and living rooms suitable, not really expensive and in addition small and inconspicuous. But how do the small message units actually work and which ones? Differences is there? Basically, there are three types:

  1. Photo-optical smoke detector
  2. Thermo-optical smoke detector
  3. Ionisation

This sounds like advanced physics, but is explained in a few sentences. The photo-optical Variants, are also called photo-electric designated. One means one and the same. This species is common and is integrated in popular models. In the small smoke chamber, a diode is used, which emits an infrared light. If there are smoke particles in the chamber, their light is broken. The scattered light is detected by integrated sensors and the smoke detector signals alarm. This technology is recommended because of the rapid response in the home.

YouTube

By downloading the video you accept the privacy policy of YouTube.
Read more

Load video

Thermo-optical smoke detector also detect smoke concentrations and also record an increased ambient temperature. They work like the former, but also have a thermistor. A rapidly rising room temperature heats the thermistor. In total, two are installed. The measuring heat conductor and the comparative heat conductor. The former detects the temperature rise and the latter serves as a reference. If a rapidly rising temperature is detected during the measuring process, the smoke alarm sounds an alarm. These models are not suitable for private households, as they react too slowly.

Ionisation are considered to be particularly sensitive and fast reacting. A radioactive element is located between two metal plates and emits alpha and beta rays. It develops its own current flow, which is interrupted by any smoke particles. The result is the life-saving alarm. This variant is not widely used for a good reason. Although it is reliable and the radiation harmless, if the device remains closed. However, they are considered hazardous waste. If a fire occurs, the remains of the smoke detector would be in ruins. The radiation would now be free and would eventually pull all the debris with it as hazardous waste. We advise against it!

Minimum features for smoke detectors according to DIN EN 14604

A smoke detector needs some Criteria meet to get the certification. The criteria include, for example:

  • An alarm volume of at least 85 dB (A)
  • Recurring alarm already 30 days before battery end
  • Test button on the detector
  • Smoke must be able to penetrate into the test chamber from all sides

Smoke detector should carry the CE mark including the test number and have the suffix "EN 14604". More and more is also the Q-Label by highlighting some gadgets.

Smoke detector for the hearing impaired

Blind people generally have a well-developed sense of smell and can save themselves in an emergency. People without impairment anyway. But what about deaf people?

For their protection were special aids created. Since a noisy siren does not help, other variants must act as lifesavers. The so-called shaker is considered a successful alternative to acoustic variants. It fits under the normal pillow and is invisibly connected to a smoke detector with radio module.

The correct setup of this wireless connection is extremely important and makes an assistant indispensable. Once the first test is passed, a deaf or hearing impaired person can sleep soundly.

The best examples are products from Ei Electronics. The Ei605TYC-D smoke detector with associated radio module Ei605MTYRF-D is on everyone's lips and guarantees maximum safety. The cost here is fast on 500 Euro, with a Costs Acquisitione can be requested from the health insurance company. This must be in writing and serves to cover the total costs. Smoke alarms serve basic safety needs and must be approved (see http://juris.bundessozialgericht.de/cgi-bin/rechtsprechung/document.py?Gericht=bsg&Art=en&nr=13510).

There are also innovative light signal technology, which makes a Stoboskopleuchte necessary. The very bright light signal is also perceived at night by the retina and thus registered. The message system should be mounted in a suitable location to get the full effect.

Mini Design smoke detector

Networking technology of smoke detectors - radio networking

Wireless networking is worthwhile for very large residential units that are separated from one another by many walls. They are coupled with each other and are also based on battery operation. Just like all other smoke alarms, this way they are not dependent on the power grid. If a fire alarm detects a source of fire in the house, it forwards this information to the other devices. That way you get the vital information everywhere. The technique is simple. There is a master device (transmitter) and a slave device (receiver). Tech-savvy people in particular like to use radio transmission. It is recommended, as our smoke detector comparison showed, to use alarm units from the same manufacturer. This way, possible compatibility problems are eliminated. This method is reliable when properly installed, but also more expensive.

Install smoke detectors correctly

The Gland on the ceiling is the safest and generally recommended. Dowels and matching screws are usually included in the sets and make it easy for beginners. A short operating explanation is easy to understand and provided with illustrations. For those who do not want to, stand innovative bonding process is available for storage, management and analysis.

Tips for fixing in general:

  • Always attach to the ceiling, as smoke rises
  • Always in the center of the room and 50 cm away from the wall
  • Always position horizontally, never put on the slope
  • Never in wet rooms like bathrooms or kitchens due to steam
  • Never install near air ducts or ducts

Take care when Fire detector comparison to the feature "installation" to make the right choice.

Smoke detector Buy 1mal1

As well as large test procedures of the Stiftung Warentest show, the price is relative. The following points are essential in the purchase decision:

Technology

The conventional photo-optical method is still recommended and has the fastest response. Pay attention to the additional photo-optical or photo-electric order at the smoke detector.

Lifespan

There are models with integrated lithium battery that last for many years. Others demand regular battery replacement, which can be nerve-racking in practice. In addition, the sensor play the biggest role, as it goes blind with time. The so-called contamination compensation regulates the sensitivity of the sensor in order to trigger as few false alarms as possible. Therefore, in addition to the long-life battery and this factor should be considered when buying smoke detectors.

Installation

The secured method is the screwing on the ceiling. If you do not want to screw, you should use adhesive technology. The reporting systems are simply and safely pressed and are also certified. When buying a smoke detector, pay attention to the instructions for installation. Incidentally, this takes less than 5 minutes!

usability

With regard to the operation, the control knob is meant. The function key is considered to be comfortable if it can be operated from the ground during the smoke detector check. You do not have to jump, just use a broomstick. Also the LED signal t for some comfort, for others annoying. In the fire detector comparison you can recognize the function at first glance.

networking

For very large living areas, networking of all fire detectors is suitable. Most come with single devices that often cover 60 m².

Stiftung Warentest smoke detector comparison

At the right time has the popular and reliable editors of Stiftung Warentest taken stock again. In the Output 01 / 2016 Twenty smoke detectors between 17 and 103 Euro were scrutinized to give clear recommendations for private households. It turned out to be a new thing that expensive is not equally good. Only ten smoke detectors have passed "good". The cheap one Egg Electronics Ei650 was also winner in the local smoke detector test winner and a high-priced competitor test loser. In any case: sure is safe!

Smoke detector not installed despite compulsory - what then?

The good thing in advance: as long as it does not burn, nothing happens! After all, nobody will control someone else's property. Such supervisory bodies are neither permitted nor intended.

But it should be the worst scenario, one Brand If the fire brigade and Co were forced to attend the circumstances, On the one hand, the potential source of fire must first be located. In the same breath, a fire fighter might ask for smoke detectors. And then?

In the home it becomes more or less considerable damage to property give, which underlie the fire. Your insurance may not want to settle these losses if it has been proven that no smoke detectors have been installed or missed this step.

However, it should be noted here that the smoke detection systems are installed exclusively to live to protect. Property damage is a completely different construction site and therefore this point always remains to be clarified by the lawyer in case of doubt.

The Gesamtverband der deutschen Versicherungswirtschaft eV, already commented on this issue. A missing smoke detector would have to be quasi cause for the fire, in order to lose claims. As a rule, however, such a connection can not be established. Normally, it would not ask any insurer for proof of incorporation or the like, since it was primarily about the life saved.

If it is rent property, the landlord is responsible for the smoke detection systems. If the duty had been neglected here, that would be bitter.

OTHER RECOMMENDED SMOKE DETECTIVES WANTED FOR YOU

What an article received when comparing smoke alarms Test-Vergleiche.com a "very good"?

The Smoke Detector Egg Electronics Egg 650 Smoke Detector Fire Detector was rated as “Very Good” by far in our comparison and was chosen as “Best Recommendation” compared to other articles.

Which manufacturers offer in the smoke detector comparison of Test-Vergleiche.com Your products?

Our smoke detector comparison is based on a number of well-known manufacturers. With us you can easily find out which product in the smoke detector belongs to which brand. We have chosen these manufacturers for you: Egg Electronics, Hekatron, Pyrexx , Busch-Jäger and elro.

Who puts the article in the smoke detector comparison that offers the best price-performance ratio?

According to the objective assessment of our editors, the Smoke Detector Pyrexx Fire Detector from the smoke detector comparison the evaluation as an article with the best price-performance ratio.

What do the smoke detector products cost in the Test-Vergleiche.com Comparison are presented? 

You are already getting smoke detector products 16,35 € to buy. If you place more value on high-quality products, you should pay up to 46,99 € expected.

Which smoke detector manufacturer was selected by the editorial staff of which smoke detector products Test-Vergleiche.com included?

In what order did the editors of Test-Vergleiche.com the smoke detector article prized?

We research objectively, competently and independently of industry, media & Co. In our smoke detector comparison, customer experiences, our own test results and possible evaluations by Stiftung Warentest have led to this ranking: The article got 1st place Smoke Detector Egg Electronics Egg 650 Smoke Detector Fire Detector, followed by Smoke detector Hekatron Genius PLUS the smart smoke detector fire detector, Smoke Detector Pyrexx Fire Detector, Smoke detector Busch-Jäger fire detector and Smoke detector Elro Cavius ​​Smoke detector Fire detector.

Which top products belong to the smoke detector comparison of Test-Vergleiche.com?

Our smoke detector comparison is mostly based on 5 different bestsellers, of which our editorial team chooses one in first place and one gets the rating as the price-performance winner. The other three Smoke Detector Egg Electronics Egg 650 Smoke Detector Fire Detector, Smoke detector Hekatron Genius PLUS the smart smoke detector fire detector and Smoke Detector Pyrexx Fire Detector but are at least as good, but only one can be the winner.

Jonas
Author test-vergleiche.com

Updated January 13, 2024

Smoke detector test & comparison guide – your guide to the optimal product

Discover in our Smoke detector test and comparison guidehow to choose the perfect product for your needs.

Greetings from the world of nature! My name is Jonas, an enthusiastic hobby mountaineer, cyclist and angler. Mine leisure I often spend time in the most beautiful camping areas in the world. In addition to my passion for outdoor activities, I am also interested in sporting events and, thanks to my professional work in the automotive industry, in cars and motorcycles.

As an experienced author at Beste-Testsieger.de, where I go for the main categories DIY & Tools, leisure, Drug Store, Budget, Electronics, Home & Living, Fashion and Cars & Motorcycles My greatest concern is to share my passions with you. I hope you find exciting suggestions and inspiration in my smoke detector comparison.

My carefully compiled table offers you an overview of the top 5 smoke detector bestsellers. The basis of my selection is sales figures, survey results, smoke detector test reports and customer reviews.

I also keep an eye out for tests from Stiftung Warentest and share the results in my guide. My goal is to make the cost-benefit factor of the products clear to you to make your decision easier.

I would really appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to share your experiences - my portal at Beste-Testsieger.de and its wide range of categories is available to you around the clock.

Further links and sources too smoke detector

Wikipedia smoke detector

Further information about our article can be found under Wikipedia, a platform of the most popular free encyclopedias on the Internet. Here you will learn a lot of interesting facts and information about our selection on the smoke detector to look up.

Youtube smoke detector

If you are on the YouTube video portal real and concrete information about our products smoke detector search, this source of information gives you direct access to the appropriate video clips.

Amazon smoke detector

On the platform of Amazon You can discover almost every product you want to buy online. So you will find this too smoke detector Product on Amazon. At the same time, many more articles can be found for your search on this portal.

Ebay smoke detector

Ebay is one of the world's largest online marketplaces where you can also discover our articles. Next to the smoke detector from commercial traders you will also find the smoke detector as used items from private sellers

Best recommendation

Smoke Detector Egg Electronics Egg 650 Smoke Detector Fire Detector

4.7 / 5 - (171 votes)
Price-performance winner

Smoke Detector Pyrexx Fire Detector

4.5 / 5 - (180 votes)

The latest product tests and comparisons 2023


Page comment

Your email address will not be published

4.6 / 5 - (885 votes)