Charcoal Test - Comparisons. Com 2024

The best charcoal in comparison

The best charcoal for the perfect barbecue evening

Many people grill regularly, but often do not know which charcoal to use. The result: bad taste or even soot taste! With our help you are guaranteed to find the perfect charcoal for your next barbecue evening!

Illustration
Best recommendation
Charcoal Weber 17591 briquettes 8kg
Price-performance winner
Charcoal LotusGrill beech charcoal 2,5 kg
Charcoal Grill Republic table grill charcoal 2,5kg & fuel paste 500ml
Charcoal McBrikett KOKOKO EGGS Premium, 8 kg organic coconut
Charcoal firewood Moser charcoal beech for BBQ, large, 20kg
Charcoal BBQ Kontor 20kg (2x10kg) premium beech charcoal
Charcoal BlackSellig 20 kg steakhouse charcoal
Charcoal Knight's Firewood 20 kg (2x10kg) premium charcoal
Charcoal McBrikett KOKOKO CUBES Premium, 8 kg organic coconut
Charcoal Profagus 10 kg - charcoal briquettes Grillis Sommerhit
Model Charcoal Weber 17591 briquettes 8kg Charcoal LotusGrill beech charcoal 2,5 kg Charcoal Grill Republic table grill charcoal 2,5kg & fuel paste 500ml Charcoal McBrikett KOKOKO EGGS Premium, 8 kg organic coconut Charcoal firewood Moser charcoal beech for BBQ, large, 20kg Charcoal BBQ Kontor 20kg (2x10kg) premium beech charcoal Charcoal BlackSellig 20 kg steakhouse charcoal Charcoal Knight's Firewood 20 kg (2x10kg) premium charcoal Charcoal McBrikett KOKOKO CUBES Premium, 8 kg organic coconut Charcoal Profagus 10 kg - charcoal briquettes Grillis Sommerhit
Details
Brand Weaver Lotus grill Grill Republic mcbriquette Firewood Moser Bbqkontor Blacksellig Knight'S Firewood mcbriquette profane
Result
The Best producttest-vergleiche.com1,5Very good!
Price-value for moneytest-vergleiche.com1,7good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com1,6good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com1,8good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com1,9good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,0good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,1good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,2good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,3good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,4good
Weight price per kg 8 kg approx. €1,87 2,5 kg approx. €6,36 2,5 kg approx. €7,99 10 kg approx. €3,00 20 kg approx. €1,54 2 x 10 kg approx. €1,60 20 kg approx. €4,14 2 x 10 kg approx. €1,60 8 kg approx. €3,62 10 kg approx. €3,10
Species old wood Beech wood Beech wood coconut briquettes Beech wood Beech wood quebracho wood Beech wood coconut briquettes Beech wood
charcoal
Burning behavior 10 9 9 8 9 9 10 9 8 10
Benefits
  • particularly long burning time
  • low smoke emission
  • Charcoal briquettes - good flame development
  • long burning time
  • minimal smoke
  • including fuel paste
  • fast ignition
  • very high calorific value
  • Burning time up to 6 hours
  • long burning time
  • Burning time up to 6 hours
  • for a pleasant beech wood aroma
  • with steakhouse grain from 40 to 120 mm
  • good temperature
  • long burning time
  • large to very large pieces of charcoal
  • rapid development of embers
  • large to very large pieces of charcoal
  • very high calorific value
  • long burning time
  • particularly long burning time
  • low smoke emission
  • rapid development of embers
  • Charcoal briquettes - good ember development
to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer
charcoal

Charcoal at a glance

  • You can buy charcoal in two different versions. Once as charcoal or coconut charcoal and once as evenly shaped charcoal briquettes. The type of wood has a significant influence on the taste of the food to be grilled and the shape has an influence on the burning behavior.
  • In the carbonization of wood, the wood is carbonized without the supply of oxygen. That's why she charcoal the advantage that it quickly gets hot and glows through. This ember lasts about an hour and can be used to grill meat & co.
  • With the barbecue briquettes things are a bit different. They take longer to heat up and glow more slowly. But they keep the embers much longer than conventional charcoal.

Top product: charcoal on Amazon

Weber 17591 briquettes 8kg
  • charcoal
  • Colour: Black
  • Pack Weight: 8.17 kg
  • Pack size: 17.5 L x 63.6 H x 33.5 W (cm)

It depends on the charcoal

Summer and barbecuing simply belong together. As soon as the first rays of sunshine warm up, the grills are taken out of the shed and the grill cutlery cleaned. But which charcoal is suitable and what is the best way to light it? Only the right charcoal gives meat and fish the right aroma and taste. But what is the difference between a high-quality Weber charcoal (see our charcoal comparison winner from the table) and the inexpensive charcoal from the supermarket? So that you can optimally contest your next barbecue evening, we have researched the various charcoal offers for you and put this charcoal comparison guide together.

What is charcoal?

Charcoal or barbecue charcoal as well as barbecue briquettes consist of the carbonaceous residues that result from combustion with the lowest possible air supply. All varieties are an ideal fuel that maintains heat for a long period of time. To light them, high temperatures are required, which is best achieved with a charcoal chimney starter or a electric grill lighter. We would like to introduce you to the individual types of charcoal:

charcoal

wood charcoal

Charcoal bestsellers are the charcoal products. They are best suited for direct grilling. It ignites relatively easily and quickly develops a very hot ember. The disadvantage, when the heat has subsided and is no longer sufficient for grilling, is that charcoal has to be refilled.

Advantage

  • Quickly flammable
  • ideal for direct grilling
  • reaches a good grilling temperature
  • burned embers are very even

Disadvantage

  • Smoke development when ignited
  • relatively short burning time

Charcoal Note:

If charcoal is used for the Lotus grill as Lotus grill charcoal, there is no smoke development due to the special design of the grill, in contrast to other charcoal grills.

Barbecue charcoal briquettes

An alternative to charcoal are charcoal briquettes, which are also very popular. They are usually available as charcoal briquettes 20 kg egg-shaped. They are also available in cubes or sticks. They burn for a very long time and evenly, but require a bit more stamina to light up. With a charcoal rating, these are better suited for longer barbecues than charcoal and are ideal for cooking in smoker grills, for example.

Advantage

  • Very long ember retention
  • hardly any smoke development
  • easy to portion
  • even pieces
  • for gentle cooking

Disadvantage

  • Long heating-up time
  • Wood aroma is missing
  • Less heat than charcoal

Charcoal Note:

Briquettes are also offered as coconut charcoal. It is made from coconut shells and does not require the felling of a tree. In addition, it smokes even less and the ashes can be composted. Our charcoal purchase recommendation for environmentally conscious grilling.

Our recommendation: Charcoal on Amazon

LotusGrill beech charcoal 2,5 kg! Specially developed for the low-smoke charcoal grill/table grill
  • Ignites faster
  • Glows hotter
  • CO² neutral
  • natural product
  • For approx. 15 x low-smoke grilling (basic price EUR 5,56/kg)

What is the difference between direct and indirect grilling?

  • When grilling directly, sausages and the like lie directly above the embers. You are immediately exposed to the full heat. The grilled food is seared and given its typical smoke aroma.
  • A lid is required for indirect grilling. The food is not directly above the embers, it is cooked without direct exposure to heat. Well suited for whole pieces of meat, chicken or similar.

How do I light the charcoal?

  1. Use a chimney starter
  2. Put chimney lighters, grill lighters, wood wool or kitchen paper in there.
  3. Layer fuel on top, such as charcoal or briquettes
  4. Light from below
  5. After about 20 to 30 minutes, the charcoal has formed embers and can be poured into the grill.
charcoal

Which charcoal to buy?

Here you have the choice between charcoal and barbecue briquettes. Our charcoal recommendation: you should have a bag of each type at home. This makes quick grilling possible and if the evening drags on a little longer, the embers can be extended with the grill briquettes.

What about sustainability?

If you want to be on the safe side, you should only buy charcoal with the FSC seal and pay attention to the EU standard 1860-2. This charcoal contains no slag, bitumen or artificial glue. You can also be sure that no wood from tropical forests has been used.

Where can you buy charcoal?

Charcoal is offered in different pack sizes, from 2,5 kg, 5 kg and 10 kg or sometimes as a 20 kg pack. If you store the charcoal properly, you can also stock up on supplies. Charcoal is now available in all supermarkets, in hardware stores and at gas stations. You will also find what you are looking for on the Internet, especially if you are aiming for a specific type of wood. The special thing about buying charcoal online is the charcoal price comparison, which you can only do on the Internet to get the best price-performance ratio and to get the ultimate charcoal bestseller.

What does Stiftung Warentest say about charcoal?

In the 06/2019 issue of the magazine Test, Stiftung Warentest published a charcoal test report. A distinction was made between declared, undeclared or incorrectly declared charcoal offers. That's why it's not so easy to name a charcoal test winner. It is best to read the article carefully and then decide which charcoal is best for you.

Our insider tip: Charcoal on Amazon

Grill Republic table grill charcoal 2,5kg with fuel paste 500ml - table grill charcoal made of 100% beech wood - ideal accessory for the charcoal table grill - smoke-free ...
  • 🔥 TABLE GRILL ACCESSORIES SET: The Grill Republic table grill starter set consists of a sack with 2,5 kg charcoal made of 100% beech wood ...
  • 🔥 BEECH CHARCOAL: Ideal grill charcoal made of 100% beech for optimal use for grilling with smoke-free charcoal grill ...
  • 🔥 FUEL PASTE GRILL LIGHTER: The table grill fuel paste / fuel gel is ideal for quickly lighting the charcoal without smoke....
  • 🔥 CHARCOAL TABLE GRILL WITH FAN: The Grill Republic 2,5kg charcoal and 500ml charcoal lighter set is ideal for ...
  • 🔥 FOUND: You are a passionate charcoal griller / table griller and probably after "lighting paste for table grill", "...

Conclusion

Charcoal is essential for a successful barbecue evening. Which charcoal you choose depends on your wallet and the qualities you expect from a good charcoal. As the Stiftung Warentest has determined, you cannot even trust the FSC seal. That's why you should take a close look when buying which wood was used and where its origin is.

Charcoal bestseller on Amazon:

ServicesBestseller no. 1
Weber 17590 briquettes, black, 4 kg
  • Ready to grill in just 20 minutes. Burning time: 3 hours
  • Weber's briquettes ensure a good start because they can be ignited quickly and easily and offer up to three hours...
  • These all-natural charcoal briquettes made from carbonized wood starch and water ensure long-lasting embers...
  • Long burn time - 3 hours
  • Original from Weber
Bestseller no. 2
27 kg barbecue briquettes (9 x 3 kg bags) barbecue charcoal charcoal briquettes charcoal barbecue grill
  • 🔥IDEAL HEAT: The charcoal develops optimal heat and perfect embers in about 30 minutes. Briquettes burn much longer than...
  • 🍖 EFFICIENT & ECONOMICAL: The charcoal is characterized by its economical burning behavior, so that your grilled food cooks through optimally ...
  • ✅ LESS FLYING SPARKS: If you opt for charcoal briquettes, you are making a good choice. Due to the low level of sparks and the...
  • ✅ LOW SMOKING: The charcoal ignites quickly and with very little smoking.
  • 📦 PRACTICAL PACKAGING UNITS: Choose from different containers. Conveniently packed in 3kg bags. Made in the EU.
Bestseller no. 3
Favorite barbecue charcoal 15 kg (made of pure hardwood, extra large grain size, long-lasting embers, restaurant-quality barbecue charcoal) 1500
  • Restaurant quality charcoal for optimal grilling results at your barbecue
  • High quality charcoal with extra large grains for a perfect and long-lasting glow
  • The steakhouse charcoal is made from pure hardwood and provides a tasty aroma
  • The coal is sieved and packaged in the Mecklenburg charcoal plant
  • The Lübzer quality charcoal is delivered in a 15 kg sack

What kind of article received when comparing charcoal from Test-Vergleiche.com a "very good"?

The was rated as “Very Good” by far in our comparison and was chosen as “Best Recommendation” compared to other articles.

Which manufacturers supply the bestselling products in the charcoal comparison Test-Vergleiche.com?

So that you have the best possible selection of charcoal bestsellers, you can find out in our charcoal comparison which manufacturers and brands are behind it. Here you will find such successful companies as: Weaver, Lotus grill, Grill Republic, mcbriquette, Firewood Moser, Bbqkontor, Blacksellig, Knight'S Firewood, mcbriquette and profane

Which product is correct in the charcoal comparison of Test-Vergleiche.com Price and performance?

As the charcoal item presented with the best price-performance ratio, the Charcoal LotusGrill beech charcoal 2,5 kg from us the classification regarding the best constellation.

How cheap or expensive are the charcoal products that are in the Test-Vergleiche.com Comparison were presented?

In our charcoal In comparison, you can find excellent and high quality charcoal Products whose maximum price is up to about 39,80 € can be. However, we also have cheaper alternatives for you about 12,95 €.

Which products were compared by the editors of charcoal in the charcoal comparison Test-Vergleiche.com considered?

How did the editors of Test-Vergleiche.com judged the ranking in the charcoal comparison?

After thorough research on function, own test results or publications such as a Stiftung Warentest test report or other independent specialist testers, the editorial team crowned the article Charcoal Weber 17591 briquettes 8kg to rank 1, followed by Charcoal LotusGrill beech charcoal 2,5 kg, Charcoal Grill Republic table grill charcoal 2,5kg & fuel paste 500ml, Charcoal McBrikett KOKOKO EGGS Premium, 8 kg organic coconut and Charcoal firewood Moser charcoal beech for BBQ, large, 20kg.

Which top products belong next to number 1 and the price-performance winner to the charcoal comparison of Test-Vergleiche.com?

Our charcoal comparison is mostly based on 5 different bestsellers, of which our editors choose one in 1st place and one gets the rating as a price-performance winner. The other three Charcoal Weber 17591 briquettes 8kg, Charcoal LotusGrill beech charcoal 2,5 kg and Charcoal Grill Republic table grill charcoal 2,5kg & fuel paste 500ml but are at least as good, but only one can be the winner.

David
Author test-vergleiche.com

Updated January 13, 2024

Charcoal test & comparison guide – Find your personal favorite in a variety of categories

Discover how you can benefit from our recommendations Charcoal test or comparison Your ideal product in categories like Hardware store, household, drugstore, leisure, living, electronics, fashion, car and Service Industry can select.

Hello, I'm David, a passionate believer in the do-it-yourself principle, especially in areas such as DIY & Tools and Home & Living. Before I call a repairman, I try to solve the problem myself - and I often succeed. “It doesn’t work, it doesn’t exist” is my motto. Every setback is a learning opportunity.

And you can too! Show what you've got. For this purpose I have this comprehensive one for you Charcoal comparison in a variety of categories such as Household, leisure, electronics, fashion and Cars compiled. From the multitude of offers, I have selected five of the best and best-selling Charcoal models selected and compared for you in a clear table.

My research is based on customer reviews, surveys, opinions and Charcoal tests from independent advice portals. In my guide you will find a detailed analysis that highlights both the advantages and disadvantages of each product group in these categories, as well as important purchasing criteria.

Already have your personal one Charcoal test winner found? Share your experiences and opinions with me. Your feedback is important to me and I look forward to your posting in categories like Service Industry or Drug Store!

Further links and sources too charcoal

Wikipedia charcoal

Further information about our article can be found under Wikipedia, a platform of the most popular free encyclopedias on the Internet. Here you will learn a lot of interesting facts and information about our selection on the charcoal to look up.

Youtube charcoal

If you are on the YouTube video portal real and concrete information about our products charcoal search, this source of information gives you direct access to the appropriate video clips.

Amazon charcoal

On the platform of Amazon You can discover almost every product you want to buy online. So you will find this too charcoal Product on Amazon. At the same time, many more articles can be found for your search on this portal.

Ebay charcoal

Ebay is one of the world's largest online marketplaces where you can also discover our articles. Next to the charcoal from commercial traders you will also find the charcoal as used items from private sellers

Best recommendation
Charcoal Weber 17591 briquettes 8kg

Charcoal Weber 17591 briquettes 8kg

3.9/5 - (31 reviews)
Price-performance winner
Charcoal LotusGrill beech charcoal 2,5 kg

Charcoal LotusGrill beech charcoal 2,5 kg

4.3/5 - (25 reviews)

The latest product tests and comparisons 2023


4.9 / 5 - (13 votes)