Screw extractor test - comparisons. Com 2024

The best screw removers in comparison

The "left-handed" trick

A rounded screw head with none combination wrench more engages or a screw head with the use of a wrong one screwdriver The tool has become unsolvable, poses a great challenge. If you have to drill it out, the thread of the borehole may be damaged, which would lead to even greater problems.

A clever alternative is a good screw extractor setwith which the screw can be removed in a moderate way. The thread is not damaged and the old screw can be replaced without any problems. in the Screw extractor set offer there are various designs.

SCREWDRIVER SET
AIR IMPACT WRENCH
RATCHET SCREWDRIVER SET
MAKITA ACCESSORIES
sort by  
  Best recommendation

offer screw extractor GEDORE screw remover set

1,5Excellent

Screw extractor GEDORE screw remover set
  •  Screw extractors only
  •  pretty tough
  •  easy-grip thread

go to the offer

  

on offer Niudai screw extractors 5 pieces screw remover

1,6good

Screw extractor Niudai 5 pieces screw remover
  •  high hardness
  •  durable
  •  2-in-1 solution

go to the offer

 Price-performance winner

for offer Screw extractor Daoxue screw remover set

1,7good

Screw extractor Daoxue screw remover set
  •  works with any drill
  •  2-in-1 solution
  •  great hardness

go to the offer

  

on offer Screw extractor DIYARTS screw remover set

1,8good

Screw extractor DIYARTS screw remover set
  •  Easy to use
  •  with drill set and holding key
  •  Drill and puller can be used separately

go to the offer

  

offer Jellas 22PCS screw extractor screw remover

1,9good

Screw Extractor Jellas 22PCS Screw Remover
  •  with extension bit holder
  •  without turning around
  •  with bit holder and adapter

go to the offer
Name Screw extractor GEDORE screw remover set Screw extractor Niudai 5 pieces screw remover Screw extractor Daoxue screw remover set Screw extractor DIYARTS screw remover set Screw Extractor Jellas 22PCS Screw Remover
Price Check price Check price Check price Check price Check price
comparison result
Note on the comparative grade

The Best producttest-vergleiche.com1,5ExcellentScrew extractor

TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com1,6goodScrew extractor

Best Performance test-vergleiche.com1,7goodScrew extractor

TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com1,8goodScrew extractor

TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com1,9goodScrew extractor
Manufacturers Gedore Niudai Daoxue DIYARTS Jella's store
Material Chrome vanadium steel HSS 4341 HSS 4341 Chrome vanadium steel HSS 4341
Number of essays 5 5 5 11 22
temper 54 HRC 62 ?? 63 HRC 62 ?? 63 HRC 58 ?? 60 HRC 64 ?? 65 HRC
removes screw sizes M3 ?? M18 M4 ?? M12 M4 ?? M12 M3 ?? M18 M2 ?? M12
Tool for repositioning no ja ja no no
Tool type Screw extractor 2-in-1 drill including screw extractor 2-in-1 drill including screw extractor Drill + screw extractor individually Drill + screw extractor bits
shaft for Gedore tool holder with ratchet (Art.-No. 8551 TG) Hexagonal shank Hexagonal shank Square shaft Hexagonal shank
other versions also with shallow drilling depth no as socket adapter or adapter for inch sizes no no
Transportbox Plastic box Plastic box no Truckbox Truckbox
Features Drills must be provided separately works with every drill and every screw gold Drills can also be used for other work 24 Months Guarantee
Benefits
  •  Screw extractors only
  •  pretty tough
  •  easy-grip thread
  •  high hardness
  •  durable
  •  2-in-1 solution
  •  works with any drill
  •  2-in-1 solution
  •  great hardness
  •  Easy to use
  •  with drill set and holding key
  •  Drill and puller can be used separately
  •  with extension bit holder
  •  without turning around
  •  with bit holder and adapter
Conclusion Screw extractor set with hand drive Screw remover works with any drill and screw Alloy steel screw remover tool kit Screw extractor set with tap wrench for hand drive Versatile screw extractor set with great hardness
To the Amazon offer

go to the offer

go to the offer

go to the offer

go to the offer

go to the offer

Our comparison chart for Screw extractor comparison does not replace one Screw extractor testin which a special Screw extractor test winner can be recommended. In order to increase the added value for our readers, we may link to an external screw extractor test of trustworthy sources. Only you decide which model is your personal one Screw extractor test winner is.

Screw extractor

Screw extractors at a glance

  • A screw extractor set helps to gently remove broken or damaged screws. You can also easily remove rounded screw heads or broken or rusted ones from the drill hole with a screwdriver set.
  • Screw extractor sets are suitable for all defective types of screws. Either a drill with clockwise, counterclockwise rotation required, one Boring machine and a tap wrench to unscrew with muscle power.
  • Most screw extractor sets are so-called left extractors, right extractors are only required for screws, for example on rims that are not allowed to unscrew in the direction of travel.

It's annoying when a screw cannot be unscrewed for whatever reason. Most of the time, they can only be removed with great force and damage to the objects that are to be freed from the screw. So-called screw extractors offer a non-violent solution. Inserting them requires a bit of skill, but the end result is usually a thread that has remained intact, into which you can easily insert a new screw. What you need to consider in a screw extractor set and which purchase criteria you should consider is what they want you to know Screw extractor set comparison from Test-Vergleiche.com explain in more detail.

 

Top product: screw extractor at Amazon

GEDORE screw extractor set, chrome vanadium steel, 54 HRC, in transparent plastic box, 5 pieces, M3-M18
GEDORE screw extractor set, chrome vanadium steel, 54 HRC, in transparent plastic box, 5 pieces, M3-M18
  • Robust screw extractor for easy removal of broken screws
  • Uncomplicated alternative to drilling out, ideal in connection with the separately available tool holder with ratchet from GEDORE ...
  • High quality chrome-vanadium steel with 54 HRC, for thread pitches M3-M18
  • Including a transparent plastic box for safe storage
  • SCOPE OF DELIVERY: 1 x 5-piece screw extractor set in a transparent plastic box, M3-M18, chrome vanadium steel, 54 HRC, ...
Amazon Prime
TO OFFER

What is a screw extractor set?

Screw extractors are mostly left-handed extractors and are also known as pig tails or grave diggers. It is required for a right-hand thread, screw in clockwise, screw out counter-clockwise. Left-hand threads, for example on wheel nuts, are tightened to the left and loosened to the right. Right-handed tools are primarily, however Professional screw extractor set Tools that are mostly needed for rotating things, such as on the car. A screw remover is a tool that can remove the remains of broken, rusted or round screw heads. If you have a Buy screw extractor set would like, you won't know in advance which screw size has to be unscrewed. Therefore, screw extractor sets come in a number of different sizes and shapes.

To unscrew the screw you need 3 steps:

  1. A hole is drilled in the head of the broken screw
  2. A conical screw extractor with a milled thread is inserted into the hole
  3. The screw is unscrewed with a drill or tap wrench

Screw extractor note:

Most buyers will be one Left-hand thread screw extractor set but if you need a combined screw extractor set for right and left-hand threads, buying a double-edged screw extractor set is worthwhile. Buying one is also worthwhile for wheel nuts that are stuck Impact wrench.

Screw extractor

The simple screw extractor

To use the simple screw extractor, you first need to use a dry drill drill a hole in the screw head. The hole diameter must be drilled in the specified size of the screw extractor. The tool itself has a slim shape with a conical shape tapering at the tip. The conical tip has a milled left-hand twist all around and is screwed into the drilled hole to the left. The other side has a socket for a tap wrench. The screw extractor is anchored in the hole with muscle power and as soon as it has enough grip, it unscrews the broken screw.

Screw extractor note:

The hole in the screw head must not be too large. Otherwise, the edges of the screw could press apart when unscrewing, making it very difficult to unscrew. See also the table "Standard sizes and bit peaks"

Screw extractor advantages / disadvantages

Benefits

For removing screws with damaged screw heads

Has a longer thread than the 2-in-1 screw extractor sets and is therefore less prone to failure

cheap when different drill sizes are required

good hold in the tap

Disadvantages

Additional drill bits are required

Unscrewing mostly only with tap wrench

The 2-in-1 screw extractor

These models are among the most popular screw extractor sets. With them you don't need any additional drills, as the drill and extractor are on the same bit, just on different sides. These screw extractor sets are very practical because they have the right drill size for the right extractor. You only need to change the bit and no additional tools are required. All you need is a screwdriver with clockwise and counterclockwise rotation.

2-in-1 screw extractor sets advantages / disadvantages

Benefits

For drilling and removing screws with damaged screw heads

No additional tools required

Drill and extractor available on the same bit

cheaper

Disadvantages

Right-hand and left-hand drill required

not as powerful as it has a shorter thread

Daoxue screw extractor

Daoxue screw extractor
BEST OFFER *

The unit of measurement HRC

It is certainly understandable that the tool has to be harder than the screw to be loosened. The hardness of a metal is given with the unit of measurement HRC (Hardness Rockwell), the last letter "C" stands for the test scale. As a rule, the hardness grades of screws go up to about 44 HCR, which means that the tool for unscrewing screws must necessarily be harder. In our research on the inexpensive screw extractor sets we found hardness levels of around 55 HCR in the screw extractors. The 2-in-1 screw extractors have a hardness of 60 to 65 HCR, because the drill should have a slightly greater hardness here.

Standard sizes and bit tips

It is quite possible that you can no longer tell from a defaced screw which screw size is behind it. This is especially difficult to see if the screw head has broken off. The best screw extractor sets indicate in their operating instructions which attachment is required for which size. That is why many manufacturers indicate the approximate diameter of the drill hole for the standard size of the screw. For example, with an M8 screw, you should not select a tip diameter greater than 4,5 mm.

Standard size screwBit tip diameterStandard size screwBit tip diameter
M3 - M62,5 mmM14 - M188,0 mm
M6 - M83,0 mmM18 - M2411 mm
M8 - M114,5 mmM24 - M3313,5 mm
M11 - M146,0 mmM33 - M4518,5 mm

Screw extractor note:

The sizes can be slightly different for the different manufacturers, so take a look at the Screw extractor set instructions with the guidance.

Using the example of Gedore screw extractor sets the following values ​​result:

  • Size 0 = distance from screw size 2-4 mm
  • Size 1 = distance from screw size 3-5 mm
  • Size 2 = distance from screw size 4-8 mm
  • Size 3 = distance from screw size 5-10 mm
  • Size 4 = distance from screw size 6-12 mm

First, make sure that the drill bits you are using are smaller than the screws you are removing. Start with the drill and drill a hole. Now take the extrusion point and change the drill direction or take the tap wrench at hand. Apply pressure slowly or rotate at a low speed. The extractor bites into the screw and pulls out the damaged screw.

Screw extractor bestseller on Amazon:

ServicesBestseller no. 1
STONE REEF screw extractor set professional [5-piece from HSS 4241] - left extractor set professional, extractor, screw extraction tool, left-hand screwdriver set, ...
STONE REEF screw extractor set professional [5-piece from HSS 4241] - left extractor set professional, extractor, screw extraction tool, left-hand screwdriver set, ...
  • ✅ Easy to use - These extractors can be used to remove screws with broken heads...
  • ✅ Easy to use - The extractor set with a hexagonal shaft is suitable ...
  • ✅ Excellent quality - The structured thread structure ensures a...
  • ✅ 𝐈𝐍𝐊𝐋. Easy to use - thanks to the included tool box made of ...
  • ✅ Excellent quality - The left-hand extractor set is made of robust and durable 4341 steel, which ...
Amazon Prime
TO OFFER
ServicesBestseller no. 2
Newder screw extractor set, 5 pieces damaged screw remover extractor set for removing slightly damaged screws, made of HSS 4341 ...
Newder screw extractor set, 5 pieces damaged screw remover extractor set for removing slightly damaged screws, made of HSS 4341 ...
  • 【Wide Compatibility】 - The bolt puller set (#0/#1/#2/#3/#4) works with any drill and screw or screw...
  • 【Hardness 63hrc】 - This damaged screw remover tool set is made of HSS 4341 (hardness is 63hrc) alloy ...
  • 【Offers a 2-in-1 solution】 - The two-step solution saves you the hassle of using more than one tool to pull out the ...
  • 【Designed with two bits】 - The high-speed steel extractors are also designed with two bits to speed up the extraction process ...
  • 【Wide application】 - The damaged screw puller and the damaged remover can often be used during repair work in ...
Amazon Prime
TO OFFER
ServicesBestseller no. 3
BGS 1896 | Screw extractor set | Sizes 1 - 6 | 6 pcs.
BGS 1896 | Screw extractor set | Sizes 1 - 6 | 6 pcs.
  • for removing torn off/sheared screws and studs
  • carbon steel
  • in plastic box
  • suitable for the following screws:
  • 3 - 6mm (1/8" - 1/4")
Amazon Prime
TO OFFER

Our screw extractor set purchase advice

It can always happen that a screw can no longer be loosened for a variety of reasons. Our Screw extractor set buy recommendation was therefore always such a set in the tool bag to have. Common sets are suitable for screws from M2 to M12 and the Screw extractor set price is not high for it. The expense is definitely worth it if you are over a job and the mishap occurs. Who then only one Hornbach or OBI screw extractor set must procure, knows the existing tool in the Toolbox appreciate. However, it doesn't matter if you have one Order or buy screw extractor set onlineYou should memorize a few purchase criteria.

  • Screw extractor set with right-hand or left-hand thread?

That is actually the most important differentiator in the Screw extractor set rating, On Screw extractor set, left-hand thread is always required when a screw to be loosened has been screwed in clockwise. In the case of rotating parts, such as on the car wheels, the screws must always be screwed in to the left so that they cannot loosen when the wheels turn. In that case a Screw extractor set, right-hand thread thats it!

  • Which sizes are important?

Of course it's great when the best screw extractor set includes all possible sizes. In reality, however, only a few sizes are required. That is why most screw extractor sets are offered in 5 pieces for the common sizes from M4 to M12.

  • What is cheaper 2-in-1 or just a borer?

The 2-in-1 screw extractor sets have a drill on one side and a conical extractor on the other. This saves additional tools by simply moving the tool. What is needed for this, however, is a drilling machine with clockwise and counterclockwise rotation. This is ideal for all smaller screw sizes. However, if you want to unscrew a larger screw, one drill hole is usually not enough. You have to start small and then later drill the hole a little bigger. In that case it is cheaper to use a Metal drill set to be used separately and then remove the drilled screw with the tap wrench.

  • Where can I buy screw extractor sets?

Screw extractor sets are available in most hardware stores. Who one Screw extractor set purchase advice needed, should only buy in tool shops. For everyone else and also for those who do Screw extractor set cheaper want to buy yours should Buy screw extractor set online. A great advantage of online trading is the ability to get one Screw extractor set price comparison to make between the different providers.

  • Who makes good screw extractor sets?

First and foremost, these are all well-known tool manufacturers. Special mention should be made here Hazet screw extractor sets, which from Bosch, Gedore or the popular Wera screw extractor sets. But many other manufacturers also offer a wide range of screw extractors.

Screw extractor

Answers (FAQ) to the screw extractor set comparison

A screw extractor set is there to remove broken, rusted or rounded screws. It consists of different sizes and shapes. In addition to the screw remover, the 2-in-1 screw extractor sets also have the right drill on the same tool. Other screw removers require separate drills.

Drill sizes and screw removers are matched to one another in terms of size. The drill is used to make a hole in the broken screw head, into which the conical screw remover is inserted later. It literally bites into the screw head and you can loosen the screw without any effort.

Depending on the size and hardness of the screw extractor sets, there are corresponding costs. For a simple set of 5 units, you usually don't have to pay more than 15 to 20 euros.

Unfortunately, there is still no screw extractor set test report and therefore no screw extractor set test winner that we could present to you.

Most common threads are right-hand threads. To remove it you have to turn the screw to the left. A screw extractor set with anti-clockwise rotation is therefore a tool that can loosen right-hand threads.

All common screws are compatible for removing screws with a screw extractor set. Regardless of the screw head, whether slotted or Phillips, hexagon or Torx, the screw remover does not care.

Most of the mountings are hexagonal and will fit into any drill press. For the models with square either a tap wrench is attached or, if the square is also to be clamped into the drill, there is an adapter.

Double-edged screw extractor sets can be used for both right-hand and left-hand screws. This saves a second set of screw extractors.

Where can the titanium case be bought?

The titanium case is not only available from specialist dealers, but also in various shops on the Internet. The individual manufacturers lead to a comprehensive Titanium case offerso that the desired model can be perfectly tailored to your own needs. At the same time the customer has the opportunity to receive an informative Titanium case price comparison to get the right model at an attractive price. The following manufacturers offer the popular titanium cases online:

  • Markenkoffer
  • Titanium case Store
  • Real
  • luggage market
  • Karstadt
  • amazon

Conclusion to the titanium case

A titanium case combines high quality workmanship with an elegant design. The manufacturer offers a large selection of suitcases that are ideal for both short breaks and long trips. At the Buy titanium case different points play an important role. This includes, for example, the volume, the material and the equipment, so that ultimately all things can be reasonably accommodated.

What item received when screw extractor comparison of Test-Vergleiche.com a "very good"?

The Screw extractor GEDORE screw remover set was rated as “Very Good” by far in our comparison and was chosen as “Best Recommendation” compared to other articles.

Which manufacturers have the products in the screw extractor comparison of Test-Vergleiche.com dominates?

Among the screw extractors bestsellers, we have selected these successful companies for you in the screw extractor comparison. Here you can find such leading manufacturers or brands as: Gedore, Niudai, Daoxue, DIYARTS and Jella's store

Which product is correct in the screw extractor comparison of Test-Vergleiche.com Price and performance?

As the screw extractor item presented with the best price-performance ratio, the Screw extractor Daoxue screw remover set from us the classification regarding the best constellation.

Which products from the screw extractor comparison of Test-Vergleiche.com are expensive, which ones are affordable?

In the Screw extractor Products in an exquisite version, the costs are correspondingly high and are with us up to a proud price of 31,79 € to find. On the other hand, you can already start the articles in the lower price category 14,99 € magazine.

Why did the editors of Test-Vergleiche.com in the screw extractor comparison these articles taken into account?

Our editorial team deals with a wide range of providers for every comparison before deciding which articles from which manufacturers compete against each other in the screw extractor ranking. Here were these 5 godparents: Screw extractor GEDORE screw remover set, Screw extractor Niudai 5 pieces screw remover, Screw extractor Daoxue screw remover set, Screw extractor DIYARTS screw remover set and Screw Extractor Jellas 22PCS Screw Remover

How did the editors of Test-Vergleiche.com judged the ranking in the screw extractor comparison?

After thorough research on function, own test results or publications such as a Stiftung Warentest test report or other independent specialist testers, the editorial team crowned the article Screw extractor GEDORE screw remover set to rank 1, followed by Screw extractor Niudai 5 pieces screw remover, Screw extractor Daoxue screw remover set, Screw extractor DIYARTS screw remover set and Screw Extractor Jellas 22PCS Screw Remover.

What was in the screw extractor comparison of Test-Vergleiche.com next to the comparison winner and the price-performance winner?

In addition to the best screw extractor items and the price-performance winner, there are other, also very good products in our selection that last: Screw extractor GEDORE screw remover set, Screw extractor Niudai 5 pieces screw remover and Screw extractor Daoxue screw remover set.

David
Author test-vergleiche.com

Updated January 13, 2024

Screw extractor test & comparison guide – Find your personal favorite in a variety of categories

Discover how you can benefit from our recommendations Screw extractor test or comparison Your ideal product in categories like Hardware store, household, drugstore, leisure, living, electronics, fashion, car and Service Industry can select.

Hello, I'm David, a passionate believer in the do-it-yourself principle, especially in areas such as DIY & Tools and Home & Living. Before I call a repairman, I try to solve the problem myself - and I often succeed. “It doesn’t work, it doesn’t exist” is my motto. Every setback is a learning opportunity.

And you can too! Show what you've got. For this purpose I have this comprehensive one for you Screw extractor comparison in a variety of categories such as Household, leisure, electronics, fashion and Cars compiled. From the multitude of offers, I have selected five of the best and best-selling Screw extractor models selected and compared for you in a clear table.

My research is based on customer reviews, surveys, opinions and Screw extractor tests from independent advice portals. In my guide you will find a detailed analysis that highlights both the advantages and disadvantages of each product group in these categories, as well as important purchasing criteria.

Already have your personal one Screw extractor test winner found? Share your experiences and opinions with me. Your feedback is important to me and I look forward to your posting in categories like Service Industry or Drug Store!

Further links and sources too Screw extractor

Wikipedia Screw extractor

Further information about our article can be found under Wikipedia, a platform of the most popular free encyclopedias on the Internet. Here you will learn a lot of interesting facts and information about our selection on the Screw extractor to look up.

Youtube Screw extractor

If you are on the YouTube video portal real and concrete information about our products Screw extractor search, this source of information gives you direct access to the appropriate video clips.

Amazon Screw extractor

On the platform of Amazon You can discover almost every product you want to buy online. So you will find this too Screw extractor Product on Amazon. At the same time, many more articles can be found for your search on this portal.

Ebay Screw extractor

Ebay is one of the world's largest online marketplaces where you can also discover our articles. Next to the Screw extractor from commercial traders you will also find the Screw extractor as used items from private sellers

Best recommendation

Screw extractor GEDORE screw remover set

4.6 / 5 - (19 votes)
go to the offer
Price-performance winner

Screw extractor Daoxue screw remover set

4.5 / 5 - (28 votes)
go to the offer

The latest product tests and comparisons 2023

Page comment

Your email address will not be published

4.6 / 5 - (184 votes)