Training collar test - comparisons. Com 2024

The best training collars in comparison

Training collar: How to help your dog with behavior training

Training collars are controversial in the dog training scene. While some dog owners find them an effective tool in dog training, others discourage the use of training collars. In this guide you will learn everything you need to know about training collars. We will introduce you to the different types of training collars, explain the advantages and disadvantages as well as the risks and give you important tips for successful use.

Illustration
Best recommendation
Training collar Hunter training harness Follow Me XL
Price-performance winner
Training Collar TRIXIE 13003 Top Trainer training harness
Training collar ILEPARK dog halter with padded fabric
Training collar Halti Optifit Headcollar
Training collar Hunter Freestyle training collar, robust
Training collar beaphar Gentle Leader® size M
Training collar Halti OptiFit head halter for dogs
Training collar Ruffwear Flat Out Collar, Classic, size S
Training collar Hunter SOLID EDUCATION training collar
Training collar Cesar Millan Original Illusion Collar, size S
Model Training collar Hunter training harness Follow Me XL Training Collar TRIXIE 13003 Top Trainer training harness Training collar ILEPARK dog halter with padded fabric Training collar Halti Optifit Headcollar Training collar Hunter Freestyle training collar, robust Training collar beaphar Gentle Leader® size M Training collar Halti OptiFit head halter for dogs Training collar Ruffwear Flat Out Collar, Classic, size S Training collar Hunter SOLID EDUCATION training collar Training collar Cesar Millan Original Illusion Collar, size S
Details
Brand Hunter Trixie Ilepark Halti Hunter Beaphar Halti Ruffwear Hunter Cesar Millán
Result
The Best Suggestionstest-vergleiche.com1,5Very good!
Price-value for moneytest-vergleiche.com1,7good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com1,6good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com1,8good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com1,9good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,0good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,1good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,2good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,3good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,4good
problem area pulling on the leash pulling on the leash pulling on the leash pulling on the leash pulling on the leash pulling on the leash pulling on the leash pulling on the leash pulling on the leash pulling on the leash
max. neck circumference k. A. 48 cm about 40 cm 62 cm 60 cm k. A. k. A. 36 cm about 45 cm 38 cm
sound function
Method train coach train coach train coach train coach train coach train coach train coach train coach train coach train coach
Operation manually manually manually manually manually manually manually manually manually manually
Activation Line range inherent to the train Line range inherent to the train Line range inherent to the train Line range inherent to the train Line range inherent to the train Line range inherent to the train Line range inherent to the train Line range inherent to the train Line range inherent to the train Line range inherent to the train
water resistant
Benefits
  • Available in plus sizes
  • suitable for aggressive dogs and such
  • who pull very hard.
  • also in sizes S
  • L
  • L/XL and XL available
  • adjustable chin strap
  • Also available in other sizes
  • also suitable for barking and biting.
  • good fit
  • available in other sizes
  • adjustable chin strap
  • slightly shortened overall length
  • Easy to use
  • optimal fit
  • better leadership and control
  • maximum comfort for your dogs
  • light and robust nylon straps
  • easy to attach and detach
  • suitable for puppies
  • made of non-slip cowhide
  • with a locking ring
  • also in size M
  • Size L and red available
  • good fit.
to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer
Training collar1

Training collar at a glance

  • The use of training collars is prohibited by law in some countries and regions as it is considered cruelty to animals. For example, training collars in Germany are only permitted under certain conditions and may only be used by people who have a certificate of competence.
  • The use of training collars should always be done with care and consideration. It is important that the collar is fitted correctly and that the dog is never in contact with it for longer than necessary. In addition, the effort should always be combined with positive reinforcement and praise.
  • There are different types of training collars that differ in how they work and how they work. For example, some collars only emit a sound or vibration, while other collars use electrical impulses. Before purchasing a training collar, it is important to find out about the different types and choose the right collar for your dog.

Top product: training collar on Amazon

HUNTER training harness Follow Me XL
415 reviews
HUNTER training harness Follow Me XL
  • Gentle dog training aid due to the possibility of easy pulling on the bridge of the nose and neck, even for aggressive and very strong pulling...
  • Easy handling with versatile functions for dog training and education
  • Natural movements are not hindered
  • The headgear can easily be converted into a neck
  • e.g. Rottweiler

Everything you need to know about training collars

Dog training isn't always easy, and sometimes it takes more than positive reinforcement to train a dog. An often discussed tool in the dog training scene is the training collar. But what exactly is a training collar and how is it used?

What is a training collar?

A training collar is a dog training tool that is placed around the dog's neck and emits various signals to influence the dog's behavior. There are several types of training collars, including remote training collars, spray collars, vibrating collars, and electric shock collars. These collars are often used as a last resort to correct unwanted dog behavior.

How is a training collar used?

The use of training collars should always be done with care and consideration. Before a training collar is used, dog owners should obtain sufficient information and seek advice from an expert. A training collar should never be the only tool for dog training, but always used as a supportive tool. It is important that the collar is fitted correctly and that the dog is never in contact with it for longer than necessary. In addition, the effort should always be combined with positive reinforcement and praise.

Where does the training collar come from?

The origins of the training collar go back to the 60s, when it was first used in dog training. The idea behind the training collar was to create a tool that would help the dog owner to control and correct the dog's behavior. Since then, the training collar has evolved and today there are different types of collars with different functions and modes of action.

What is a training collar for?

A training collar is designed to correct unwanted dog behavior and help the dog learn desired behavior. For example, it can be used to signal the dog to stop barking, pulling, or chasing. However, a training collar should always be used with caution and caution, as improper use can lead to pain and stress in the dog.

Training collar2

Types of training collars

There are different types of training collars that differ in how they work and how they work. Here are the characteristics of the most common types of training collars:

Type of training collarcharacteristics
remote trainer collarControllable via a remote control; emits either a sound or an electrical pulse.
spray collarEmits an unpleasant odorant to correct unwanted behavior.
vibration collarVibrates on dog's neck to correct unwanted behavior.
electropulse collarWhen triggered, emits an electrical pulse to correct undesirable behavior.

Training collar advantages / disadvantages

Benefits

  • Training collars can help correct unwanted dog behavior.
  • They are usually quick and precise effective.
  • They can also be used in difficult situations such as dogs with aggressive behavior.
  • They can be useful to help train the dog, especially when other methods don't work.

Disadvantages

  • Improper use can cause pain and stress in the dog.
  • Some dog trainers and animal rights activists consider the use of training collars to be cruelty to animals.
  • There is a risk that the dog will misinterpret the signal or that the owner will misapply it, which can lead to unwanted behavior.
  • The use of training collars can also cause the dog to develop anxiety or trust issues.

Our recommendation: training collar on Amazon

Top trainer training harness, M: 27 cm
603 reviews
Top trainer training harness, M: 27 cm
  • Without leash (must be combined with V-leash)
  • webbing
  • Helps to clarify the rank by imitating the dog's typical muzzle grip
  • Light impulses can prevent the dog from making eye contact, e.g. B. be interrupted to another animal
  • Serves for education and is not a walking harness for long-term use

Is the training collar legal in Germany?

The training collar is a controversial tool in dog training. Many people wonder whether the use of training collars is legal in Germany or not. Here's what you need to know:

  • Legal basis
    In Germany, the use of training collars for dogs is permitted by law. However, there are some restrictions and regulations that must be observed. The use of training collars is only permitted for private use and may not be used for commercial purposes. The use of training collars is only permitted for adults who have had sufficient training and experience in dog training.
  • Restrictions and Regulations
    Although the use of training collars is allowed in Germany, there are some restrictions and regulations that must be observed. For example, training collars may only be used for specific behavior problems such as barking or pulling on the leash. The use of aggressive behavior training collars is prohibited.
    In addition, the electrical impulses must only have a low strength and must not harm the dog or cause pain. The use of training collars must also always be combined with positive reinforcement and rewards.

Alternatives to the training collar

If you are looking for alternatives to the training collar, there are several ways to train your dog and correct unwanted behavior.

  • positive reinforcement
    An alternative to the training collar is positive reinforcement. This method is based on rewarding the dog for good behavior instead of punishing him for bad behavior. Examples of positive reinforcement include food rewards, praise, and toys.
  • clicker training
    Clicker training is another alternative to the training collar. A small device is used that makes a clicking sound when the dog shows the desired behavior. The dog is then rewarded, which helps it learn the desired behavior.
  • Halti or dishes
    A halter or harness can also be an alternative to the training collar. These tools give the dog owner more control over the dog without causing pain. They can help correct unwanted behaviors like leash pulling.

Only use as a last resort
A training collar should always be used as a last resort and should never be the only tool in dog training. Positive reinforcement and praise should always come first.

Training collar bestseller on Amazon:

Bestseller no. 1
Palma Store, training collar for dogs, 45cm length adjustable for smaller breeds, self-adjusting collar for dogs, collar for dogs,...
7 reviews
Palma Store, training collar for dogs, 45cm length adjustable for smaller breeds, self-adjusting collar for dogs, collar for dogs,...
  • Comfortable and safe: Self-adjustable collar made of soft rubber, ideal for dogs of all sizes, from large to small, ...
  • Versatile for any occasion: Perfect for both training and daily walks, this collar offers a...
  • Innovative design: Equipped with safe and external rubber elements that are effective but painless, it protects the dog,...
  • Easy adjustment: 45 cm length with self-adjustable adjustment system, allows a perfect fit for dogs of different...
  • Quality and durability: Made from high quality materials, the collar is sturdy, durable and easy to clean, which...
Bestseller no. 2
Pet Corrector Dog Training. Helps stop unwanted behavior: barking, jumping, stealing food, dog fighting, dog attacks, keeps dogs away from...
2.306 reviews
Pet Corrector Dog Training. Helps stop unwanted behavior: barking, jumping, stealing food, dog fighting, dog attacks, keeps dogs away from...
  • STOPS BARKING: Supports dog training to stop unwanted behavior; Barking, jumping, stealing food,...
  • SAFE, PET-FRIENDLY AND NATURAL Hissing Pet Corrector uses air to emit a harmless hissing sound, mimicking...
  • IDEAL FOR DOG TRAINING We love our dogs. This is why animal-friendly training is so important. Pet Corrector is a...
  • EASY TO USE WITH INSTANT RESULTS: 3 easy steps to a well-behaved dog. BHG Watch: the...
  • SAFETY AND USE: Not suitable for puppies or anxious dogs. Always read the instructions for use before use;...
Bestseller no. 3
Anti Bell Gerät Hunde, Antibell Ultraschall Gerät mit Variabler Frequenz, Handheld Anti Bellen Gerät Antibell für Hunde, Antibell Halsband Hund, Anti Bell...
3 reviews
Anti Bell Gerät Hunde, Antibell Ultraschall Gerät mit Variabler Frequenz, Handheld Anti Bellen Gerät Antibell für Hunde, Antibell Halsband Hund, Anti Bell...
  • 【Sicheres und effektives Anti Bellen Gerät】Der verbesserte Zweifrequenz-Ultraschall kombiniert feste und variable Frequenzen, so...
  • 【Antibell für Hunde Gerät ist einfach zu bedienen】Sie brauchen nur den Knopf zu drücken, und wenn Sie den Piepton hören, zeigt...
  • 【Ultrasound to Stop Dogs from Barking】Ultrasonic specially designed to stop dogs from barking. Of the...
  • 【Handliches und tragbares Design】Unser Ultraschall Hundeabwehrgerät ist kompakt und tragbar. Einfach zu tragen, wenn Sie mit Ihrem...
  • 【Kundenbetreuung】Unser Hundetrainingsgeräte wird mit einer kostenlosen Garantie und einem 45-tägigen bedingungslosen...

How are training collars tested?

Training collars are tested by various trade magazines to rate their effectiveness and safety. Various criteria such as the mode of action, handling, processing and material quality are evaluated.

  • Test procedure

Testing of training collars is mostly carried out by experienced dog trainers and experts. The collar is tested on different dogs and its effect and handling are evaluated. Attention is also paid to whether the collar causes pain or stress to the dog and whether it is safe and reliable.

  • Trade magazines and reviews

There are various trade magazines that have tested training collars. These include the magazines "Hund und Halter", "Ein Herz für Tiere" and "HundeWelt". Collar ratings vary by magazine and review, so it's a good idea to compare multiple sources.
Well-known manufacturers or brands for training collars

There are several well-known manufacturers and brands of training collars, including:

  • Petsafe
  • Dogtra
  • SportsDOG
  • Garmin
  • E-Collar Technologies
  • Educator

Where can you buy training collars?

Training collars can be purchased at many online and retail pet supply stores. Some well-known online shops that offer training collars are Amazon, Zooplus and Fressnapf. Retailers such as Fressnapf, Kölle-Zoo or Dehner also have training collars in their range. It is important when purchasing a training collar to ensure that it fits your dog and your needs and that it is from a trusted manufacturer.

Get expert advice
Before you decide to use a training collar, you should seek advice from an expert and find out about the different types of collars and their uses.

Training collar3

You should consider this before buying a training collar

Before you buy a dog training collar, there are a few things you should consider to ensure you choose the right product for your dog. Here are some important considerations:

  • Fitting
    It is important to ensure that the training collar fits well and is comfortable for your dog. It should not be too tight or too loose to avoid accidental triggering.
  • Operation
    There are different types of training collars, all of which have different effects. Before you buy, find out which collar is best for your dog's specific behavior.
  • Handling
    Be sure to use the training collar safely and correctly. Be sure to read the manufacturer's instructions and, if necessary, seek advice from an experienced dog trainer.
  • Safety
    It is important to ensure that the training collar is safe, reliable and does not pose any unnecessary risks to your dog. Check the material quality and make sure the collar has no sharp edges or loose parts.

Why it pays to buy a training collar

A training collar can be a useful tool in correcting unwanted behavior in your dog. It can help you respond to behavior problems more quickly and effectively, and teach your dog what to do and what not to do more quickly.

What you should definitely know about training collars

It's important to realize that the use of training collars is controversial and that there are alternatives such as positive reinforcement that are just as effective for most dogs. It is also important to understand that training collars are only effective and safe when used correctly and responsibly.

correct application
It is important that the training collar is fitted correctly and only used for a short period of time. The dog should never be in contact with the collar for longer than necessary and use should always be combined with positive reinforcement.

Our insider tip: training collar on Amazon

Dog Halter with Safety Belt Head Harness for Dogs to Stop Pulling, Adjustable and Easy to Control (S, Red)
2.172 reviews
Dog Halter with Safety Belt Head Harness for Dogs to Stop Pulling, Adjustable and Easy to Control (S, Red)
  • STOP PULLING: This dog collar prevents pulling by gently guiding your dog's forward direction while walking...
  • MULTIFUNCTIONAL: Thanks to the round metal ring, you can easily connect the dog collar to a leash. It is practical,...
  • SUPERIOR: Our dog halter is made of strong and durable nylon. The comfortable and soft padding prevents...
  • HUMANIZED DESIGN: Adjustable neck straps and buckle are easy to use and you can choose the most comfortable length for your...
  • NOTE: We recommend that you measure your dog's muzzle before purchasing a dog collar, our size chart can be found in...

Conclusion on the training collar

A training collar can be a useful addition to your dog's training when used responsibly and safely. However, it is important to read up on the different styles, modes of action and limitations and make sure it suits your dog and your needs.

Surveys on the subject of training collars

We'd love to hear your opinions and experiences about the training collar. Please answer some of the following questions and leave your answer in the comment box:

  1. Have you ever used a training collar on your dog?
  2. How did you use the training collar?
  3. How long have you been using the training collar?
  4. Has the training collar improved your dog's behavior?
  5. Do you have concerns about using training collars?
  6. Have you already tried alternative methods of dog training?
  7. Would you use a training collar as a last option?
  8. Did you do enough research before buying a training collar?
  9. How important is the opinion of experts (veterinarians, dog trainers) to you when using training collars?
  10. How important is your dog's safety to you when using training collars?

What kind of product has in the training collar comparison of Test-Vergleiche.com earned a top spot?

The product earned the top spot in our ranking and took the crown among all other, also very good products.

Wer sind die Hersteller, die sich im Ranking des Erziehungshalsband Vergleichs von Test-Vergleiche.com have excelled?

Die Anzahl der Hersteller, die Erziehungshalsband Produkte anbieten, ist sehr groß. Damit Sie sich auf die besten Produkte konzentrieren können, haben wir in unserem Erziehungshalsband Vergleich bekannte Produkt dieser Hersteller Hunter, Trixie, Ilepark, Halti, Hunter, Beaphar, Halti, Ruffwear, Hunter and Cesar Millán selected for you.

Who is the item that offers the best value for money in the training collar comparison?

According to the objective assessment of our editors, the Training Collar TRIXIE 13003 Top Trainer training harness from the training collar comparison, the evaluation as an article with the best price-performance ratio.

Which products from the training collar comparison? Test-Vergleiche.com are expensive, which ones are affordable?

In the Erziehungshalsband Products in an exquisite version, the costs are correspondingly high and are with us up to a proud price of about 44,90 € to find. On the other hand, you can already start the articles in the lower price category about 4,49 € magazine.

Which products were rated in the training collar comparison by the editors of Test-Vergleiche.com considered?

In what chronology were in the training collar comparison of Test-Vergleiche.com the products classified?

What was next to the comparison winner and price-performance winner in the training collar comparison of Test-Vergleiche.com selected other top products?

All products from the training collar comparison were edited by the editors of Test-Vergleiche.com Selected for popularity and top ratings, including these top products such as Training collar Hunter training harness Follow Me XL, Training Collar TRIXIE 13003 Top Trainer training harness and Training collar ILEPARK dog halter with padded fabric.

Jonas
Author test-vergleiche.com

Updated January 13, 2024

Training collar test & comparison guide – your guide to the optimal product

Discover in our Training collar test and comparison guidehow to choose the perfect product for your needs.

Greetings from the world of nature! My name is Jonas, an enthusiastic hobby mountaineer, cyclist and angler. Mine leisure I often spend time in the most beautiful camping areas in the world. In addition to my passion for outdoor activities, I am also interested in sporting events and, thanks to my professional work in the automotive industry, in cars and motorcycles.

As an experienced author at Beste-Testsieger.de, where I go for the main categories DIY & Tools, leisure, Drug Store, Budget, Electronics, Home & Living, Fashion and Cars & Motorcycles My greatest concern is to share my passions with you. I hope you find exciting suggestions and inspiration in my training collar comparison.

My carefully compiled table offers you an overview of the top 5 training collar bestsellers. The basis of my selection is sales figures, survey results, training collar test reports and customer reviews.

I also keep an eye out for tests from Stiftung Warentest and share the results in my guide. My goal is to make the cost-benefit factor of the products clear to you to make your decision easier.

I would really appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to share your experiences - my portal at Beste-Testsieger.de and its wide range of categories is available to you around the clock.

Further links and sources too Erziehungshalsband

Wikipedia Erziehungshalsband

Further information about our article can be found under Wikipedia, a platform of the most popular free encyclopedias on the Internet. Here you will learn a lot of interesting facts and information about our selection on the Erziehungshalsband to look up.

Youtube Erziehungshalsband

If you are on the YouTube video portal real and concrete information about our products Erziehungshalsband search, this source of information gives you direct access to the appropriate video clips.

Amazon Erziehungshalsband

On the platform of Amazon You can discover almost every product you want to buy online. So you will find this too Erziehungshalsband Product on Amazon. At the same time, many more articles can be found for your search on this portal.

Ebay Erziehungshalsband

Ebay is one of the world's largest online marketplaces where you can also discover our articles. Next to the Erziehungshalsband from commercial traders you will also find the Erziehungshalsband as used items from private sellers

Best recommendation
Training collar Hunter training harness Follow Me XL

Training collar Hunter training harness Follow Me XL

4.6/5 - (24 reviews)
Price-performance winner
Training Collar TRIXIE 13003 Top Trainer training harness

Training Collar TRIXIE 13003 Top Trainer training harness

4.8/5 - (26 reviews)

The latest product tests and comparisons 2023


4.3 / 5 - (60 votes)