Luggage carrier bag test - comparisons. Com 2024

The best pannier bags in comparison

Luggage carrier bag - The bag for the bike

While baskets were used on a bike until a few years ago, luggage rack bags are now bestsellers much more attractive. They are available in different versions in order to be able to adapt them perfectly to the respective bike.

The main advantage of the best luggage rack bag is that the contents are kept safe at all times. This gives you the opportunity to go shopping by bike, even in bad weather, without your purchases getting completely wet.

Illustration
Best recommendation
Pannier bag VAUDE Aqua Back bike bag – waterproof
Price-performance winner
Luggage carrier bag Büchel bicycle bag for luggage carriers
Pannier Bag Basil Women's Magnolia Pannier, Teal Blue
Pannier bag Ortlieb Adult Back-Roller Classic Ql2.
Pannier bag Ortlieb Back-Roller City, Red-Black 40L, F5001
Luggage carrier bag FISCHER luggage carrier bag for the bicycle
Pannier bag Rhinowalk bicycle bag 20L TPU waterproof
Pannier bag HiLo sports 2 pieces waterproof 25L bike
Luggage carrier bag KLICKfix bike bag Backpack, black, M
Pannier bag Rohtar 3in1 bike bag - waterproof
Model Pannier bag VAUDE Aqua Back bike bag – waterproof Luggage carrier bag Büchel bicycle bag for luggage carriers Pannier Bag Basil Women's Magnolia Pannier, Teal Blue Pannier bag Ortlieb Adult Back-Roller Classic Ql2. Pannier bag Ortlieb Back-Roller City, Red-Black 40L, F5001 Luggage carrier bag FISCHER luggage carrier bag for the bicycle Pannier bag Rhinowalk bicycle bag 20L TPU waterproof Pannier bag HiLo sports 2 pieces waterproof 25L bike Luggage carrier bag KLICKfix bike bag Backpack, black, M Pannier bag Rohtar 3in1 bike bag - waterproof
Details
Brand Vaude Büchel Basil Ortlieb Ortlieb Fischer rhino walk Hilo Sports click fix Rohtar
Result
The Best Suggestionstest-vergleiche.com1,5Very good!
Price-value for moneytest-vergleiche.com1,8good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com1,6good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com1,7good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com1,9good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,0good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,1good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,2good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,3good
TOP Productstest-vergleiche.com2,4good
Material Tarpaulinwaterproof, tear-resistant Tarpaulinwaterproof, tear-resistant Polyester tear-resistant, robust Polyester tear-resistant, robust Polyester tear-resistant, robust pvc | Polyester tear-resistant, robust TPUwaterproof, tear-resistant, fire-resistant Tarpaulinwaterproof, tear-resistant Polyester tear-resistant, robust Tarpaulinwaterproof, tear-resistant
mounting easy to install easy to install easy to install easy to install easy to install easy to install easy to install easy to install easy to install easy to install
completely waterproof
Lock roll closure roll closure Buckle closure Buckle closure Buckle closure Buckle closure Buckle closure Buckle closure zipper Buckle closure
stability especially stable especially stable especially stable especially stable especially stable especially stable especially stable especially stable especially stable especially stable
incl. carrying strap
Dimensions (L 33 x 19 x 37 cm 56,5 x 30 x 15 cm 39 x 18 x 35 cm 33 x 16 x 60 cm 33 x 16 x 60 cm approx. 35 x 45 cm no manufacturer information 34 x 20 x 47 cm 38 x 14 x 44 cm 33 x 17 x 40 cm
reflective elements
Volume 48 l | each bag 24 l 25,4L | a bag of 25,4 l 18L | each bag 9 l 40 l | each bag 20 l 40 l | each bag 20 l 23l | a bag 23 l 20l | a bag 20 l 50l | a bag 25 l 42 l | each bag 21 l 25L | a bag 25 l
Benefits
  • Roll closure also waterproof
  • very good workmanship
  • very large capacity
  • particularly good workmanship
  • particularly waterproof even in heavy rain
  • no tools required
  • Quick fastening system
  • including accessories for different pipe diameters
  • particularly good workmanship
  • the bags can be used separately
  • including accessories for different pipe diameters
  • particularly good workmanship
  • the bags can be used individually
  • the workmanship is particularly good
  • the bag can be carried like a backpack
  • to use fast fastening system
  • particularly good workmanship
  • particularly good workmanship
  • particularly waterproof even in heavy rain
  • divisible interior
  • particularly good workmanship
  • Main compartment can also be opened from the front
  • particularly good workmanship
  • available in other colors
  • particularly waterproof
  • even in heavy rain, the bag can be carried like a backpack
to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer to offer
pannier bag

Luggage carrier bag at a glance

  • The pannier bag is suitable for every situation, whether in leisure time or simply for shopping. Thanks to different sizes, it offers enough space inside and can therefore be used individually.
  • Most pannier bags are also equipped with a shoulder strap or even with a waist strap. This means that the bags can also be transported by hand without any problems when it comes to bringing the contents into the apartment.
  • To ensure that the contents are really protected, most manufacturers use waterproof and tear-resistant material. As a rule, these are robust plastic or truck tarpaulins, which are also available in different colors and designs.

Top product: pannier bag on Amazon

VAUDE bicycle bags for luggage rack Aqua Back 2x24L in blue 2 x rear wheel bags waterproof, bicycle luggage rack bag at the back, easy attachment - Made...
  • SIMPLE: Thanks to the QMR 2.0 fastening system, the bike bag fits on round luggage rack tubes with diameters of 8-16 mm. Light...
  • SPACE: The bicycle luggage rack bag offers 2 x 24L storage space. The spacious main compartment, the inside pocket and the wrap closure,...
  • APPLICATION: The VAUDE bicycle bag can be used as a bicycle bag and shoulder bag and is therefore particularly practical in everyday life. The...
  • MATERIAL: The waterproof bicycle bags for luggage racks are made of high-quality tarpaulin material and are PVC-free...
  • SUSTAINABLE: VAUDE has been climate neutral since 2022. Emissions that cannot currently be avoided are completely covered by “myclimate”...

What is a pannier bag?

As the name suggests, these are bags that are attached to the luggage rack of the bicycle. They are suitable for different purposes and thus ensure that the content is protected at all times. Right off to go shopping, in the leisure or to make longer bike rides, the best luggage carrier bag offers reliable storage space that can vary greatly in size. This is not least due to the fact that these bags are now available in different sizes, so that they can be optimally adapted to the desired use.

Essentially, a distinction is made between three models of pannier bags. On the one hand there are the classic side bags that are attached to the luggage rack and offer a lot of storage space. In addition, there are pannier bags, which are of course attached directly to the luggage rack. Here, however, you should pay attention to whether an additional bracket is necessary to make a corresponding attachment possible here. Finally, you will find the so-called triple bags in the extensive range, which are usually attached to the luggage rack and are perfectly attached there thanks to a fixed assembly.

pannier bag

What are the different pannier bag variants?

As we have already mentioned in our luggage carrier bag comparison, a distinction is essentially made between three models. We would like to briefly explain the features of these models and how they are used below:

  • The side pockets

These are very classic and traditional luggage carrier bags that are attached to the sides of the luggage carrier. They are simply hung in, impress with a lot of storage space and can of course also be used individually. As a rule, they are equipped with a practical shoulder strap, so that they can also be easily transported by hand at the end of the day. Thanks to the different sizes that are now available in this area, the bags can be wonderfully adapted to your own requirements.

  • The triple bag

In addition to the side pockets, there are additional pockets that are attached to the luggage rack. The triple bag convinces with a fixed assembly, different sizes and of course an individual division inside. Due to the many different compartments, you can sort your personal things wonderfully without having to search for them for a long time.

  • The suitcase bag

In contrast to the side bag, the pannier bag is attached directly to the luggage rack. In order to get an optimal attachment here, luggage carrier bags test reports show that in this case a separate holder is often required. The advantage of this bag is that it is usually used both as a backpack and as a shoulder bag.

Our recommendation: luggage rack bag on Amazon

Services
Büchel bike bag for luggage rack I 25.4 L - 100% waterproof I with carrying handle and shoulder strap I bike bag luggage rack, luggage rack bag, bicycle ...
  • A bag for everything - whether for mounting on the luggage rack, for casual carrying with the included shoulder strap or with the...
  • Safe on the road - protected from wind and weather thanks to your waterproof premium bike bag with special compartments for...
  • Lots of space - For big adventures you need big bags, with dimensions of 56,5 x 30 x 15 cm and a volume of 25,4 L ...
  • For all luggage racks - Thanks to our innovative and variable fastening system, the bike bag fits on almost every luggage rack.

What should be considered when buying a pannier bag?

If we now look at the different pannier bags reviews, it becomes clear that there are a few points to consider when buying. In the following, we would like to briefly explain which criteria are important:

  • Das Modell

In our luggage carrier bag comparison, we have already mentioned that there are essentially three different luggage carrier bags. On the one hand there are the classic side bags that are located directly on the luggage rack and on the other hand the triple bag, which also has a bag that you can attach to the luggage rack. The third variant is a suitcase bag, which usually requires a separate holder. However, this bag often proves to be very useful, because in most cases it can also be used both as a backpack and as a shoulder bag.

  • The material

When it comes to the material, make sure that it is weatherproof and therefore also waterproof. Especially when you are out and about by bike, it can quickly happen that you get caught in a rain shower and the contents of the bag should therefore not be left unprotected. Most manufacturers therefore often use a stable truck tarpaulin or a mixture of cotton and nylon. Also make sure that there is a high level of stability, so that the pannier bag for the e-bike will impress you with its durability over long distances and on rough terrain.

  • The volume

The main thing here is to know what purpose the best pannier bag should be used for. While small bags have an approximate volume of 12 liters, there are also very spacious bags that have a volume of around 20 liters, for example. The larger the interior space, the more can be accommodated in the bags and the longer you can be on the road with your bike.

  • The maximum weight

The maximum weight is usually very closely related to the volume. The manufacturer does not always specify a maximum permissible weight, so you should definitely be careful when loading. If the specified weight is exceeded, it can quickly lead to the bag tearing and the contents scattering on the floor and, in the worst case, getting lost.

  • The fortification

The attachment is done in different ways and basically depends on the respective bag system. However, the pannier bag with a click system is particularly popular, as it is quick and easy to attach and detach.

pannier bag

Is there a pannier bag test by Stiftung Warentest?

As early as May 2019, the consumer magazine looked at ten different bike touring and bike city bags. The test conducted was usually about handling, durability and waterproofness, safety and of course pollutants.

In the area of ​​bicycle touring bags, the Ortlieb Back-Roller High Visibility was absolutely convincing with a quality rating of 1,5. Immediately afterwards there is also a model from Ortlieb, namely the Back-Roller Classic, which also received a grade of 1,6. The Vaude Aqua Back pannier bag was also successful and came third in the bike bag test with a grade of 1,7.

If we take a look at the bicycle city bags, we can see that a pannier bag from Vaude, namely the Augsburg III with a 1,7, was also convincing. All other models were only able to perform well, satisfactory, sufficient and poor in terms of quality.

Luggage carrier bag advantages / disadvantages

Benefits

  • Volume between 12 and 20 liters
  • Side, triple or case bag
  • Different materials
  • Can be used individually
  • tearproof
  • Waterproof
  • Easy installation

Disadvantages

  • The maximum weight must not be exceeded, otherwise it will tear

Luggage carrier bag Purchase: Specialist shops vs. Internet

As a rule, a bicycle retailer also has a certain range of pannier bags. They are now part of the classic accessories, so they can also be found in bike shops. Of course, you will often find the practical bags in hardware stores or similar shops, but there is usually only a very small range of luggage carrier bags to be found here, because the space simply does not offer more options.

An optimal alternative is without question the Internet, because there are a large number of online shops that offer a very extensive range. In addition to numerous properties, materials and sizes, you can also carry out a pannier bag price comparison in order to buy a model from a well-known manufacturer relatively cheaply at the end of the day. Examples of these manufacturers include:

  • Büchel
  • eye in
  • Sanded
  • FastRider
  • Vaude
  • Valkental
  • Manacor

Our insider tip: luggage rack bag on Amazon

Basil Women's Magnolia Pannier, Teal Blue, 39 cm x 18 cm x 35 cm
  • Material: polyester (waterproof)
  • Attachment to the luggage rack using a universal bridge system (also suitable for systems such as MIK, Racktime, i-Rack/Carrymore...
  • Reflective details

Conclusion on the pannier bag

If you like to travel by bike often, you should definitely carry pannier bags with you. Most bags offer a fairly large volume so that all the things you need can be accommodated there. Whether you use your bike to commute, ride it to the grocery store, or take it on a long weekend ride, panniers hold everything you need so you don't have to go without. Just make sure that the bag is robust and waterproof, so that the contents are optimally protected at all times and, above all, in all weather conditions.

Luggage carrier bag bestseller on Amazon:

Bestseller no. 1
travelite BASICS FOR BIKES - large bike bag, luggage rack, waterproof, with detachable shoulder strap and roll-top closure, 20 liters, 1.1kg
  • SCOPE OF DELIVERY: 1 x luggage rack bag for bicycle; Dimensions 37 x 41 x 13 cm; Volume approx. 20 liters; separate shoulder strap; Weight approx....
  • BASICS FOR BIKES: The perfect bag for every purpose - now also for the bike. With 3-point locking system consisting of two hooks and...
  • FEATURES: Waterproof tarpaulin material and welded seams make this bag waterproof. The roll top closure allows...
  • PRACTICAL: The bag is not only light and durable, but also has a removable shoulder strap. The...
  • TRAVELITE: The family-owned company based in Hamburg has been providing travelers with easy, robust and functional travel ...
Bestseller no. 2
MAXXHAUL 70209 Heavy Duty Water Resistant Softshell Tow Hitch Luggage Rack 119,4" x 50,8" Black with Tie Down Straps
  • Manufactured from PVC material with polyester reinforcement and UV coating
  • Features taped seams and a heavy duty zip that wraps around the 3 sides of the bag
  • Zipper is covered with Velcro flaps for better water protection. The zippers have large holes that...
  • (8) 3,8" wide polypropylene straps hold your bag securely to your luggage rack. Dimensions assembled (L x W x H): 35,6 x 27,9 x...
  • When in use, approximately 119,4" long x 50,8" wide x 50,8" high with a maximum capacity of 3,5m³. Can be used for a...
ServicesBestseller no. 3
VAUDE rear panniers Bayreuth III M, marine, one size, 12230
  • Office bag for cycling: welded waterproof
  • Robust and waterproof: The medium-sized Bayreuth M rear pannier in briefcase format is made of robust material with a textile look...
  • Simple and quick attachment: The bag is attached to the bicycle luggage rack using the adjustable Plug and Ride fastening rail...
  • Versatile bike bag: The small "feet" on the bottom ensure good stability, with a carrying handle or with a well-padded...
  • Another special feature: The bag is manufactured in a climate-neutral manner at the VAUDE headquarters in southern Germany, clear design and high-quality...

Which pannier bag model was rated as the winner in the Test-Vergleich.com comparison?

The article was rated as very good in our comparison cut off and prevailed against the other 5 other articles listed in the comparison.

Which manufacturers supply the bestseller products in the pannier bag comparison Test-Vergleiche.com?

So that you have the best possible choice of luggage carrier bags, you can find out in our luggage carrier bag comparison which manufacturers and brands are behind them. Here you will find such successful companies as: Vaude, Büchel, Basil, Ortlieb, Ortlieb, Fischer, rhino walk, Hilo Sports, click fix and Rohtar

Which product is correct in the pannier bag comparison of Test-Vergleiche.com Price and performance?

As the pannier bag item presented with the best value for money, the Luggage carrier bag Büchel bicycle bag for luggage carriers from us the classification regarding the best constellation.

How expensive or affordable are the products from the pannier bag comparison Test-Vergleiche.com?

Of high quality Panniers Products have their price. In doing so, you have to cost up to about 114,95 € calculate. We already have more affordable products about 23,80 € zu kaufen.

Which luggage carrier bag manufacturers were considered by the editors of Beste-Testsieger.de and which products were compared?

How were the items in the pannier bag compared by Test-Vergleiche.com rated?

The colorfully mixed items in the pannier bag comparison are almost all on an equal footing. The differences are not big and are mostly in the details. The result is the following ranking: The article is in 1st place Pannier bag VAUDE Aqua Back bike bag – waterproof followed by 2nd place Luggage carrier bag Büchel bicycle bag for luggage carriers and Pannier Bag Basil Women's Magnolia Pannier, Teal Blue, Pannier bag Ortlieb Adult Back-Roller Classic Ql2. and Pannier bag Ortlieb Back-Roller City, Red-Black 40L, F5001.

What was in the pannier bag comparison of Test-Vergleiche.com next to the comparison winner and the price-performance winner?

In addition to the best luggage carrier bag items and the price-performance winner, there are other, also very good products in our selection that last: Pannier bag VAUDE Aqua Back bike bag – waterproof, Luggage carrier bag Büchel bicycle bag for luggage carriers and Pannier Bag Basil Women's Magnolia Pannier, Teal Blue.

Jonas
Author test-vergleiche.com

Updated January 13, 2024

Luggage rack bag test & comparison guide – your guide to the optimal product

Discover in our Luggage rack bag test and comparison guidehow to choose the perfect product for your needs.

Greetings from the world of nature! My name is Jonas, an enthusiastic hobby mountaineer, cyclist and angler. Mine leisure I often spend time in the most beautiful camping areas in the world. In addition to my passion for outdoor activities, I am also interested in sporting events and, thanks to my professional work in the automotive industry, in cars and motorcycles.

As an experienced author at Beste-Testsieger.de, where I go for the main categories DIY & Tools, leisure, Drug Store, Budget, Electronics, Home & Living, Fashion and Cars & Motorcycles My greatest concern is to share my passions with you. I hope you find exciting suggestions and inspiration in my luggage rack bag comparison.

My carefully compiled table offers you an overview of the top 5 pannier bag bestsellers. The basis of my selection is sales figures, survey results, luggage rack bag test reports and customer reviews.

I also keep an eye out for tests from Stiftung Warentest and share the results in my guide. My goal is to make the cost-benefit factor of the products clear to you to make your decision easier.

I would really appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to share your experiences - my portal at Beste-Testsieger.de and its wide range of categories is available to you around the clock.

Further links and sources too Panniers

Wikipedia Panniers

Further information about our article can be found under Wikipedia, a platform of the most popular free encyclopedias on the Internet. Here you will learn a lot of interesting facts and information about our selection on the Panniers to look up.

Youtube Panniers

If you are on the YouTube video portal real and concrete information about our products Panniers search, this source of information gives you direct access to the appropriate video clips.

Amazon Panniers

On the platform of Amazon You can discover almost every product you want to buy online. So you will find this too Panniers Product on Amazon. At the same time, many more articles can be found for your search on this portal.

Ebay Panniers

Ebay is one of the world's largest online marketplaces where you can also discover our articles. Next to the Panniers from commercial traders you will also find the Panniers as used items from private sellers

Best recommendation
Pannier bag VAUDE Aqua Back bike bag – waterproof

Pannier bag VAUDE Aqua Back bike bag – waterproof

4.6/5 - (32 reviews)
Price-performance winner
Luggage carrier bag Büchel bicycle bag for luggage carriers

Luggage carrier bag Büchel bicycle bag for luggage carriers

4.5/5 - (48 reviews)

The latest product tests and comparisons 2023


4.2 / 5 - (28 votes)